About the Author

Scott Neal began work as Edina City Manager in 2010. Prior to joining the City staff, he served as City Manager of Eden Prairie since 2002. He has also held the positions of City Administrator for the communities of Northfield, Minn.; Mt. Pleasant, Iowa; and Norris, Tenn. Neal was the first City Managers in Minnesota, and one of the first in the country, to share his experiences and observations in city government in a blog and has travelled internationally to speak about his experiences with leadership blogging. Follow Scott Neal on Twitter. @edinacityman

The Stop Ahead Sign

Scott Neal, January 9, 2012 | Posted in Scott Neal

I don’t use my blog to rant, so I’ll try to keep this to a complaint and not a rant.  This is my least favorite traffic sign.  It’s called the Stop Ahead Sign.  The purpose of the Stop Ahead Sign is to warn you that you are approaching a Stop Sign, ahead.

Why do drivers need a Stop Sign Ahead sign?  I don’t know.  I know why drivers think they need a Stop Sign Ahead sign.  Drivers think they need a Stop Ahead Sign because there is some unusual twist or turn or rise in the road that so impedes their ability to see the Stop Sign ahead that it makes it impossible to stop for it, which makes it not their fault if they run that Stop Sign.

All right, that’s enough sarcasm.  But I think you know what I’m getting at.  I think the Stop Ahead Sign is frivolous.  It’s frivolous because drivers are obliged to drive at whatever speed is safe under the circumstances they are facing.   If a driver is driving so fast or paying so little attention that he or she cannot see a Stop Sign ahead, then a Stop Sign Ahead sign is not going to have the desired effect.

But the Stop Sign Ahead sign will have some effects.  It will increase the number of signs along our road sides, and the more signs along our roads, the less drivers pay attention to them, which is precisely the opposite effect that Stop Sign Ahead advocates were looking for.

Sociologically, the Stop Ahead Sign feels to me like just another sign of a permissiveness in our culture that encourages drivers to blame their failure to drive safely on institutions (cities, counties and state street & highway authorities) rather than accepting responsibility for their own mediocre driving skills and inattentiveness.

But that’s just me.  Anyway, I’m looking forward to the new Stop Ahead Sign Ahead signs.  Those are going to make our lives safer, for sure.

 

 

One Response to The Stop Ahead Sign

  1. Patrick Milan says:

    The stop ahead sign is needed on Valley View (near Braemar heading north) road where the Stop intersection is on a curve and the sign (was) on the right. The curvature of the road is such that you cannot see the sign in time to stop properly at the posted speed and the intersection is blind. Otherwise, yeah, you’re right. I was happy to see the Street Dept post a second stop sign on the
    left side so it becomes visible faster.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

DISCLAIMER: We welcome any and all comments and interaction on this page. However, posts will be moderated. Posters shall not misrepresent their identity nor impersonate any person. Comments associated with unlawful activity or that contain offensive or vulgar language or photos, personal attacks on staff members or members of the public, political endorsements of any kind, links to outside websites, commercial advertisements or any other form of commercial solicitation will not be posted.

 
  • City Blogs

    234 posts 35 posts 27 posts 74 posts 46 posts 21 posts 28 posts
  • © 2013 City Of Edina, Minnesota